Somehow we did the same sock in the same way and here is the results. Lisa has the lovliest little delicate elf sockie. My first try turned out this HUGE green honkin sock and even with a second try I can't get it small enough. Drat. I am gonna knit socks for the keychain until my head falls off or I get it right! My keychain will be the best dressed? foot in all of Michigan. Do feet get dressed?